14 June, 2017 - 16:13

WWI was one of the most horrific conflicts in all of human history and its worst aspects are being normalised in our schools. Ross Greer MSP

The Scottish Greens have slammed government ministers for their failure to condemn a ‘Dragon’s Den’ lesson plan putting children in the role of arms dealers.

After questioning by Green MSP during portfolio questions, education secretary John Swinney said that it is up to teachers to “determine the appropriateness” of external organisations visiting schools, including representatives from the defence industry.

Ross Greer, the Scottish Greens’ education spokesperson, quizzed John Swinney after it was revealed that school children are being taught using a lesson that encourages pupils to become WW1 era arms dealers in a Dragons’ Den-style scenario. Pupils are asked to come up with a battle plan, recognise the ‘advantages’ of their weapon and sell it to the Dragons. The lesson plan cites calculating the rounds per minute fired by a machine gun as an opportunity to learn numeracy and using words like ‘bayonet’ and ‘flamethrower’ to increase literacy. At no point do the resources encourage teachers or pupils to see the weapons as anything other than positive products to sell and use.

The lesson plan has previously been described as ‘popular with teacher and pupils’ by Tony McDade, head of education at South Lanarkshire Council.

West of Scotland MSP, Ross Greer said:

“It is not for politicians to approve or reject every lesson plan or teaching resource but some are just so clearly unacceptable, so grossly insensitive and so absolutely inappropriate that they should be withdrawn from classrooms. There is clear precedent for this. I cannot understand the Scottish Government hedging its bets on whether it’s ok to ask 12 year olds what problem a flamethrower or bayonet solve.

“Asking children for a sales pitch and ‘battle plan’ on how they’d use weapons is appalling and it’s absolutely outrageous that children across the country are being presented with mass slaughter not just as a game but as good business. WWI was one of the most horrific conflicts in all of human history and its worst aspects are being normalised in our schools.

“Everyone respects teacher autonomy, but I don’t see how the Scottish Government can sit on the fence on this. There was nothing remotely normal about the chemical weapons used by all sides, which burned, blinded and suffocated tens of thousands of conscripted young soldiers, or the machine guns which slaughtered many, many more as they were forced into suicidal charges towards enemy trenches. Surely the Scottish Government agrees."

Get involved

More like this

Greer steps up criticism of Scot Gov school changes as unwanted, unnecessary & risky

28 June, 2017 - 16:52

Ross Greer MSP, Education spokesperson for the Scottish Greens, used today's Holyrood Education debate to step up his criticism of the Scottish Government's school governance changes as unwanted, unnecessary and risky.

The Greens have consistently argued that the real challenge in education is the result of ten years of budget cuts, thousands of teaching and support staff and much of their resources now gone. The Scottish Government’s proposals do not address this.

Greer questions plans by Education Secretary to change educational structures

15 June, 2017 - 16:03

Ross Greer MSP, Education spokesperson for the Scottish Greens, today (15 June) questioned plans by the Education Secretary to change educational structures, including by giving headteachers greater administrative responsibilities.

The Education Secretary's proposals follow a governance review, criticised by teacher and parent representative bodies and which Mr Greer has described as a distraction from the real issue in schools: cuts to staffing.

'Teachers are already considering going on strike and rising inflation will only make the situation worse'

13 June, 2017 - 16:23

The prospect of teachers supporting industrial action was discussed at Holyrood today when a Green MSP questioned the Scottish Government’s lack of action on improving teacher salaries.

Ross Greer MSP questioned the education secretary about the freeze on teacher salaries in the wake of the EIS union voting to launch a campaign that could include strike action in response to real terms cuts in salaries over the last decade.

In response, Education Secretary John Swinney acknowledged that it was “difficult to support” the public sector pay freeze.