MSPs back Green call to scrap Council Tax

MSPs have endorsed a proposal from the Scottish Greens that the government’s upcoming reorganisation of local councils must include a replacement for the broken council tax.
On Wednesday, the party’s motion demanding that the Scottish Government set out a process for scrapping and replacing the outdated Council Tax as part of plans to reorganise local government were agreed by MSPs.
The Scottish Government is proposing a major reorganisation of local councils into two tiers of regional and community authorities, but John Swinney’s plans do not currently include a replacement of the council tax. This is despite the SNP first committing to scrap and replace the tax almost 20 years ago.
The successful Green motion stated that reorganisation must “include greater fiscal empowerment of councils, including the replacement of the current outdated council tax system with a fairer and more progressive model, and instructs the Scottish Government to lay out the process by which it aims to achieve this in its forthcoming reorganisation proposals.”
The council tax is still based on property valuations from 1991, making it wildly out of date. Many people on lower incomes are paying more than their fair share while the wealthiest benefit from a system that dramatically undervalues their homes.
The Institute for Fiscal Studies recently found that a majority of households are now paying the wrong rate of council tax due to the use of property values which are 35 years out of date.
Scottish Greens co-leader Ross Greer said:
“I am delighted that MSPs have supported Green proposals to finally replace the broken and wildly unfair council tax.
“If most people were paying the wrong rate of income tax it would be a crisis, but governments of different stripes have sat on their hands for decades with the council tax, allowing it to become comically out of date.
“If the First Minister wants Green support for his plans to overhaul Scotland’s local councils, then replacement of the council tax is non-negotiable.
“There is no point in redrawing the map if we don’t fix the finances. Our schools, social care and other essential services depend on this.
“This vote was the first step in the right direction. Now the government must work with us to agree a fairer replacement for the council tax. The Scottish Greens have already put our plans forward, but we are ready to compromise with other parties in order to get this through Parliament.
“If no proposals come forward from the government though, Green MSPs cannot support their wider council reorganisation plans.
“Someone born when the SNP first promised to scrap the council tax is now almost 20 years old – that is long enough.
“We need to go further. Greens have already proven that fairer taxes on holiday homes and empty properties can raise hundreds of millions for local services whilst tackling local housing shortages.
“But our schools are desperately short of staff and our social care system is on its knees. Reorganising councils will achieve very little if these services are still left without a fair funding system.
“Tweaking an utterly broken system isn’t good enough. MSPs have given the government a mandate to go much further. They can now work with the Greens to finally scrap the council tax and deliver a fairer funding settlement for local councils."