Wed 27 Jun, 2018

While Mr Gove’s video call to the committee is appreciated, doing so the day before parliament goes on summer recess is not helpful. John Finnie MSP

Michael Gove has been challenged by a Green MSP to close a loophole that could result in thousands of animals that are transported for fattening every year not being included in post-Brexit animal welfare legislation.

During questioning at Holyrood’s rural economy committee, the UK environment secretary asked John Finnie to forward evidence that thousands of calves leave Scotland every year for “processing” – a term used for the transportation of animals for fattening and then eventual slaughter.

Finnie, the Scottish Greens’ rural and island communities spokesperson also asked Michael Gove to apologise for appearing at the committee by video call the day before Holyrood suspends for summer recess. He says the repeated rescheduling by the UK government minister has “hindered” the committee’s attempts to hold Scottish ministers to account.

Mr Finnie, a Highlands and Islands MSP said:

“There is a glaring loophole in the UK government’s consultation on controlling live exports for slaughter during transport after the UK leaves the EU. I’m astonished that Michael Gove and fellow UK government ministers are not aware that the consultation does not include a focus on what is known as ‘processing’.

“Compassion In World Farming share my concerns about this prospective legal loophole whereby animals which are not being immediately slaughtered on arrival could still be exported. I’m astounded that Michael Gove didn’t seem to be aware, and asked me for evidence, of the fact that thousands of calves leave Scotland every year for ‘processing’, to possibly be slaughtered within days or weeks of arriving at their destination.

“There is a fine line between the definitions of ‘slaughter’ and ‘production’ and differing standards between the two categories could create a loophole. These animals must also be covered by exports legislation otherwise Brexit could have dire consequences for this country’s animal welfare standards.”

Finnie added:

“While Mr Gove’s video call to the committee is appreciated, doing so the day before parliament goes on summer recess is not helpful. His cancelling and rescheduling on several occasions has also hindered the committee’s efforts to hold the government to account on these very important rural economy issues.”

Get involved

More like this

New routes for export of live animals must prompt Ministers to rethink stance, says Ruskell

Tue 30 Oct, 2018

New routes for the export of live animals from Scotland for slaughter overseas must prompt Scottish Ministers to rethink their stance and rule out the cruel practice once and for all, according to Mark Ruskell MSP, Food & Farming spokesperson for the Scottish Greens.

Ewing under pressure to rethink support for cruel exports of live farm animals as our poll shows Scots want a ban

Thu 30 Aug, 2018

The SNP’s Rural Economy Secretary Fergus Ewing is under pressure to rethink his support for cruel exports of live farm animals for overseas slaughter, after an opinion poll commissioned by the Scottish Greens showed three out of four Scots want the practice banned.

A Panelbase poll of 1,000 Scots reveals that of those expressing an opinion, 73 per cent believe such movements should be banned, while 27 per cent believe they should be allowed. 

Mass culling of mountain hares must stop, says Finnie

Sat 25 Aug, 2018

Highlands and Islands Green MSP John Finnie has called on the Scottish Government to urgently introduce a moratorium on the culling of mountain hares in the Highlands as new figures reveal the number of mountain hares in the eastern Highlands has dropped by more than 99 per cent since 1954.

Mr Finnie said:

    “Scottish Ministers have repeatedly stated that they do not support mass culling of mountain hares, yet it is happening all the same.