Wed 22 Nov, 2017

Continued obsession with reducing the public debt, while productivity remains stubbornly low and private debt is a far bigger problem, will cause even deeper harm as a result of austerity. Patrick Harvie MSP

Patrick Harvie MSP, Finance and Economy spokesperson for the Scottish Greens, today (22 Nov) criticised the UK Chancellor for a budget that continues shameful treatment of women and families.

Patrick said:

“The Chancellor expects applause for graciously agreeing to treat Scotland’s emergency services no worse than elsewhere in the UK, while pressing ahead with the most reckless and destructive economic course of action any UK Government has ever undertaken. 

“In his claim that Brexit is a great opportunity for the economy, the first words from the Chancellor’s mouth were lies. Nobody believes that he is sincere in this claim, and we know very well that our economy, and our society, are already being damaged by the UK Government’s ‘hard Brexit’ obsession. The OBR’s downgrading of economic prospects cannot be seen as separate from that context. 

“He has thrown money at his allies in the DUP, and is now committing billions more to preparing for Brexit, while cutting our public services. 70% to 85% of cuts to public spending on benefits, taxation, pay and pensions between 2010 and 2015 come from women's incomes - it is shameful that any government should target women and their families in this way."

On the continuing austerity agenda, Patrick said:

“He’s giving even more tax cuts to high earners while failing to increase public sector pay, and his fake living wage is still set to be nearly £1 an hour below the level of the real thing. The poorest families have lost the most thanks to nearly a decade of austerity - analysis by the Women's Budget Group shows that low income black and Asian women are paying the highest price for austerity.  Carers and households where one or more family members has a disability have also been unfairly affected by cuts to support.

“Continued obsession with reducing the public debt, while productivity remains stubbornly low and private debt is a far bigger problem, will cause even deeper harm as a result of austerity. The cruel irony is that while the Chancellor gloats that government borrowing is set to fall over the coming years, this is at the expense of huge numbers of people who are struggling to make ends meet: for every £2 billion of public sector deficit reduction, the annual rate at which households have taken on new debt has increased by £1 billion.”

On the environment, Patrick added:

“Yet another round of tax breaks for the fossil fuel industry will undermine any effort the UK Government intends to make on cutting plastic pollution, while support for self-driving cars is likely to benefit the wealthiest people while public transport fares keep rising.”

And on the impact on the Scottish budget, Patrick concluded:

“The Chancellor claims there will be more capital spending for Scotland, but the impact on Scottish public services will only emerge over the coming weeks, as the Fiscal Commission produces its forecasts, and the SNP will have to decide whether to set fairer tax rates to raise the revenue that’s needed.”


Get involved

More like this

Harvie says analysis shows ministers have work to do on council funding and pay

Mon 18 Dec, 2017

Patrick Harvie MSP, Finance spokesperson for the Scottish Greens, said today's (18 Dec) draft budget analysis by the impartial Scottish Parliament Information Centre (SPICe) shows ministers have serious work to do on council funding and pay if they want support from the Green MSPs.

The SPICe analysis shows:

*The Local Government Finance Circular shows Total Revenue falling by 1.6% in real terms, or £157.3m.

*Councils could potentially raise an additional £77m, if all 32 raised Council Tax by the maximum 3%.

Our councils deliver critically important services and the decision not to provide a real terms increase to their funding must be challenged

Patrick Harvie MSP Fri 15 Dec, 2017

Derek Mackay has one of the most challenging jobs in politics. He has to construct a budget which not only balances the books, but defends against Tory austerity and meets rising demand for public services. He has to respond to the competing demands for investment in the future and also to the different views across a parliament of minorities.

Harvie welcomes plans for new rates and bands of Income Tax - Green pressure helping deliver a fairer Scotland

Thu 14 Dec, 2017

Patrick Harvie MSP, Co-Convenor of the Scottish Greens, today (14 Dec) welcomed Scottish Government plans to create new rates and bands of Income Tax, saying it shows Green pressure is helping deliver a fairer Scotland.

The Greens also say their pressure on public sector pay has led to the proposed rise of 3 per cent for workers earning up to £30,000.

But Mr Harvie warned that the draft budget fails the Greens' test on protecting council services, as ministers are proposing a real-terms cut in the local government resource budget.