Fri 10 Aug, 2018

These figures show how much scope there is to reduce the number of disability benefits assessments that so many Scots have to suffer through. Alison Johnstone MSP

Thousands of Scots could be spared from hated benefits assessment as a result of Scottish Green changes to social security law, Greens have claimed today (10 Aug).
A Freedom of Information request to the Department for Work and Pensions shows that the introduction of Personal Independence Payment (PIP) has led to an explosion in the number of unnecessary face-to-face assessments.

However, in April this year, Greens successfully amended the Social Security (Scotland) Bill to do away with assessments of people’s health or disability in order to assess a claim for a devolved benefit, unless the information cannot be obtained through any other means. The measure was introduced by Scottish Green Social Security spokesperson Alison Johnstone MSP and supported by all parties on a unanimous vote of the Parliament.
The FOI request demonstrates that under the old Disability Living Allowance (DLA) system, only 6% of applications required the applicant to undergo a medical assessment. Under PIP, the situation is almost completely reversed, with 80% of PIP applications requiring face-to-face assessment from a Health Professional working for a privatised assessment provider.
Since the introduction of PIP in 2013, 372,000 Scots have applied for PIP, suggesting that around 300,000 have undergone an in-person assessment, far more than was the case under DLA. 
Alison Johnstone MSP, Social Security spokesperson for the Scottish Greens, said:
“Figures published by the Greens today show just how many people are now being forced to undergo benefits assessments that are cruel, humiliating and in many cases, entirely unnecessary.

"The old DLA system managed to make decisions on the vast majority of claims without putting people through in-person assessments, yet the PIP system does almost entirely the opposite.
"Whilst I accept that DLA and PIP have different criteria and some caution should be exercised in comparing them, these figures show how much scope there is to reduce the number of disability benefits assessments that so many Scots have to suffer through. Putting tens of thousands of people a year through assessments which worsen their health conditions and exacerbate their disabilities, have cost £512m and are overturned on appeal 60% of the time is an absolutely unacceptable situation which must end, and the Scottish Greens have put into a law a mechanism for achieving this.
"Whilst DLA was not perfect, it does show that it is possible to design a disability benefit system that can make good use of existing evidence to reach a judgement, and not force eight in ten claimants through these awful tests that cause so much misery and so often do not produce an accurate decision.
"With cross-party support in place and now this new evidence to hand, we must fully implement the framework for assessments that Greens put into the new devolved social security law. When the first applications to the new Scottish benefit are made, this could result in many thousands of Scots getting the support they deserve without undergoing these inaccurate, hurtful and often unnecessary assessments."


Get involved

More like this

By injecting humanity into the new Scottish social security system, we can bring the giant of poverty down to size

Alison Johnstone MSP Fri 10 Aug, 2018

Three-quarters of a century ago, the economist and social reformer William Beveridge identified five issues that needed to be tackled to make a better Britain. He declared that there were five giant evils on the road to reconstruction: poverty, disease, ignorance, squalor and idleness. To defeat these giants, he proposed setting up a welfare state with social security, a national health service, free education, council housing and full employment.

New Cabinet must take bolder action to make Scotland fairer & greener

Tue 26 Jun, 2018

Scottish Green MSPs are urging Nicola Sturgeon's new Cabinet to take bolder action on making Scotland fairer and greener.

Today's reshuffle means Health Secretary Shona Robison is to be replaced by Social Security minister Jeane Freeman.

Alison Johnstone MSP, Health and Social Security spokesperson for the Scottish Greens, said:

“The role of Health Secretary is clearly one of the most challenging in Government.  Shona Robison has shown serious commitment and I wish her well for the future. 

Designing fairer devolved replacement for PIP is urgent in light of MS Society report

Tue 19 Jun, 2018

Scottish Greens Social Security spokesperson Alison Johnstone MSP has called on the Scottish Government to pay urgent attention to a new report from the MS Society which highlights the negative impact of disability welfare reforms on people with Multiple Sclerosis.

The report, published today, shows that 33% of people with MS transferred from Disability Living Allowance to Personal Independence Payment (PIP) lost support, with 10% losing entitlement entirely.