Thu 10 May, 2018

The UK government can’t even decide when to decide which customs union option to go with. Ross Greer MSP

The appearance of two senior UK government ministers at a Holyrood committee today has been called embarrassing by the Scottish Greens.

Ross Greer MSP, the party’s Europe spokesperson, says the evidence provided by David Mundell and Robin Walker shows they still don’t know what the UK’s post-Brexit custom union arrangements will look like and that the government’s indecision risks damaging the peace process in Ireland. Alarmingly, after repeated questioning, they could not confirm when a decision on customs options would be made.

After questioning by Mr Greer, the two Conservative Party MPs also declined to align themselves with Boris Johnson’s claim that a potential customs partnership would be “crazy”, with cabinet secretary David Mundell going as far as saying that he “does not feel it is appropriate for cabinet ministers to rehearse their positions in public”, in a clear rebuke to Mr Johnson. 

Greer, a member of the Scottish Parliament’s Europe and External Affairs committee, said:

“The UK government can’t even decide when to decide which customs union option to go with and they’re choosing between two options already ruled out by the EU for being unworkable. It’s embarrassing that two of the ministers responsible for negotiating the best deal possible for Scotland and the UK cannot give us something as simple as the deadline for this essential decision being made. They simply don’t recognise the huge threat to jobs and wages that their Brexit mess is causing and the damage they are on the verge of doing to the fragile Irish peace process.

“If the Tories insist on this ridiculous policy of leaving the Customs Union, then it’s likely that Northern Ireland will remain in to avoid the return of a hard border on the island of Ireland. The consequences of that for Scotland, and our west coast in particular, would be massive, with the likes of Cairnryan, and potentially Ardrossan, and other ports becoming customs borders overnight in our new frontier with Europe.

"The Tories are wasting Brexit negotiations pursuing objectively impossible positions. It came across clearly that David Mundell and Robin Walker were uncomfortable with Boris Johnson calling a proposal for a post-Brexit customs arrangement, thought to be favoured by the Prime Minister, ‘crazy’. Evidently this is a government that has no clue about what our relationship with Europe will look like the day after we leave and that should concern us all.”

Get involved

More like this

We’ve got our priorities royally wrong if we care more about the wedding in Windsor than real people’s lives

Patrick Harvie MSP Fri 18 May, 2018

Couples starting out their lives together, whether married or not, often face tough financial decisions, over issues like where to call home. If you’re very observant you might have spotted an occasional mention in the media that there’s a wedding taking place in Winsdor this weekend. Let’s all hope that the happy couple won’t have to face a grilling from their bank manager anytime soon as they set up home together.

Scotland can be a thriving, welcoming and internationalist country

Ross Greer MSP Fri 11 May, 2018

If it wasn’t obvious before, these last few weeks have shown just how rotten the UK government and its immigration systems in particular are for those unfortunate enough to experience them.

They have themselves made a far stronger case for devolving immigration & asylum powers to Scotland than we could ourselves, causing untold damage to families, communities and our national economy in the name of Theresa May’s ‘hostile environment’ policies and obsession with slashing the number of people coming to this country.

The Tories are throwing a wrecking ball at the devolution settlement

Patrick Harvie MSP Fri 4 May, 2018

When is consent not consent? This kind of question can be complicated, and when it becomes the focus of both public debate and legal process disagreements and misunderstandings can arise because of nothing more than woolly use of language. Most of us have an instinctive idea of what consent means, but until we actually discuss it openly we can’t rely on the assumption that we all share the same definition.