Fri 10 Jun, 2016

Patrick Harvie MSP

Finance, Economy, Fair Work, Equalities


Recent days have seen further revelations about many of the deeply unethical business practises, which have become routine in this country. Following the parliamentary grilling of Sports Direct and BHS bosses, it’s become clear that exploitative employers have a grip on huge sections of our economy. Scotland must face up to the challenge of shaking off such unscrupulous businessmen.

We have learned from Sports Direct owner Mike Ashley that he’s “not Father Christmas”. The chutzpah of this captain of industry, appearing before a Commons committee, was off the chart. He expected us to take pity on a simple hardworking billionaire who just couldn’t keep on top of everything in his vast empire.

Workers were paid less than the minimum wage. Employees in his warehouses were expected to walk 20 miles a day. There’s the account of one employee too scared to call in sick, resulting in a stroke at work. 200 workers at the company’s Ayrshire warehouse were sacked with only 15 minutes’ notice. Staff received harsh punishment for “excessive chatting” and toilet breaks.

The culture of fear at one site was so bad that ambulances were called out to treat staff 76 times in two years. This was immoral and in some cases illegal behaviour. Ashley clearly lined his own pockets by running a deeply exploitative business model.

Can we expect similar revelations when former BHS owner Sir Philip Green turns up next week to explain the collapse of the high street institution? The legacy he has left is the closure of 163 stores, the loss of 11,000 jobs and a pension scheme deficit of £571 million. Sir Philip and his family owned the BHS brand for 15 years before selling it to inexperienced venture capitalists for one pound. He is believed to have taken £580m out of the business in dividends, rental payments and interest on loans. He clearly has a moral responsibility to compensate those workers tossed aside like used cocktail sticks from his luxury yacht.

Green is an example of how money turns ministerial heads. Let’s remember he was knighted by Tony Blair and appointed as an adviser by David Cameron. We know what happened when Scottish First Ministers fell into the orbit of Donald Trump, and we all remember Fred the Shred of RBS infamy, who was lauded by many until he brought the bank to the point of collapse.

Time and again we see politicians weighing in to condemn such people after part of their business has got into difficulties. Wouldn’t it be refreshing instead if we challenged bullies and high stakes gamblers from the outset and made clear that the public purse will give them no encouragement and no privileges?

But what signals do we actually send? For a start, we keep dishing out public cash for dodgy employers. In recent years the Scottish Government and its agencies have handed grants and loans worth millions to groups such as Amazon, whose name is mud due to tax-avoidance and poverty pay. Ministers have defended these decisions citing job creation; but just think of the jobs we can’t create because of the missing tax revenue.

Besides, this public money could be supporting the new small independent businesses, which our communities need to develop thriving local economies.

Gambling with people’s livelihoods is simply callous and though employment law remains reserved to Westminster, we must not be afraid to push at the limits of what is possible in Scotland with the powers we do have. During the Smith Commission, the STUC advocated the transfer of employment and workplace powers but Labour, as with so much in that process, blocked the way.

We cannot wait patiently for a further round of devolution or a future independence referendum. This issue demands action right now, and if we do commit to the boldest action possible, we’ll build the case for Scotland taking real control too.

The Scottish Government’s Business Pledge is a step in the right direction.

It recognises firms meeting criteria such as paying the living wage, not using zero hours contracts and committing to diversity and gender balance.

Hundreds of firms are already accredited, ranging from Mackie’s ice cream to Hearts Football Club and City of Glasgow College.

We must go further. We must root out those who exploit workers, use tax havens or pollute the environment. At First Minister’s Questions, I challenged Nicola Sturgeon to ensure the Government’s “Fair Work” agenda contains real consequences for unethical and exploitative business practises. We can target public support towards firms that treat employees with respect and involve them in decisions, such as employee-owned businesses. We can show that a fair economy can be a successful and sustainable one.

This article first appeared in the National


Get involved

More like this

Our proposals would mean everyone earning less than the average wage would see their income tax reduce

Thu 12 Oct, 2017

The Scottish Green MSPs today (12 Oct) published a report showing how their policy of creating new rates and bands of income tax would make most Scots better off.

It comes after Scottish Ministers said they intend to bring forward a discussion paper on income tax ahead of the 2018-19 draft budget due in December.

Green MSPs gave their support for the 2017-18 budget after ministers agreed to cancel a proposed income tax cut for high earners and reverse proposed cuts of £160million to local council services. 

The government must be ready to listen before putting a budget before parliament

Patrick Harvie MSP Fri 6 Oct, 2017

Party conference season is upon us. With Theresa May’s farcical performance in Manchester earlier this week, every other leader can be confident that’d be hard put to do any worse. This weekend it’s the turn of the SNP, whose members will no doubt be eager for some positive, upbeat announcements to cheer.

The first of these was announced on Tuesday; the temporary moratorium on fracking and other forms of extreme energy production will be extended. These technologies will not be deployed in Scotland, and this will certainly feature prominently in the First Ministers speech.

We must keep pushing the Scottish Government beyond its comfort zone

Patrick Harvie MSP Fri 8 Sep, 2017

Over the summer I’ve spoken with both supporters and critics of the SNP who agree that the mood has been somewhat flat in recent years, compared with the more dynamic and innovative years of their first spell of minority government from 2007-11. The First Minister seemed to recognise this, indicating over the recess that her government had a need for a reset.