Mon 7 Oct, 2019

Alison Johnstone MSP

Health & Sport, Social Security, Children & Young People


The Scottish Government’s attempt to tackle the continued illegal killing of birds of prey by introducing vicarious liability has failed and the provision needs urgent review, Alison Johnstone MSP has said today.

Vicarious liability was introduced in 2012 as a “strong response” to the continued illegal poisoning of birds of prey. It allows for a landowner or sporting agent to be held responsible for the criminal actions of an employee, and it was hoped that it would act as an effective deterrent for wildlife crime.

However, raptor persecution continues and the Scottish Government have confirmed that there have been just two successful convictions under the vicarious liability provision over the last seven years.  In one high-profile case this year, a gamekeeper was convicted of multiple accounts of wildlife crime on Longformacus Estate, including killing protected birds of prey, but the Crown Office did not proceed with a vicarious liability prosecution.

Alison Johnstone MSP said:

“It’s unacceptable that Scotland’s birds of prey continue to be slaughtered illegally with little or no repercussion. Vicarious liability was touted by the Scottish Government as a strong response to this appalling illegality but seven years on it’s clear that it’s not working. Raptor persecution persists, and there have only been two successful convictions under this provision

“By making landowners accountable for the actions of their employees, vicarious liability was meant to act a deterrent, spurring estates and the shooting industry to  clean up their act, but it clearly has not worked. The Scottish Greens are therefore calling for a review of the law, with a view to strengthening it as part of the Scottish Government’s Animals and Wildlife Bill that will shortly be making it’s way through parliament.”

Get involved

More like this

Westminster must change gear on poverty

Tue 19 Nov, 2019

Rising levels of poverty and inequality show the need for change in the way the UK is governed, the Scottish Greens have said.

The Scottish Greens have welcomed the publication of the general election manifesto from the Poverty Alliance, which reveals how policies at Westminster drove inequalities which has left Scotland with over a million Scots in poverty, 240,000 of them children.

Scottish Greens welcome basic income pilot proposals

Alison Johnstone MSP Tue 5 Nov, 2019

The Scottish Greens have welcomed a new report into the feasibility of a Citizen's Basic Income (CBI) in Scotland.

The interim report suggests several different models for a CBI, which would be a payment to cover basic costs paid to all residents of Scotland. It would not be subject to means-testing, benefit sanctions or tax. These could be piloted for three years in selected communities.

SNP timid on short-term lets, say Greens

Fri 1 Nov, 2019

The Scottish Greens have slammed the SNP for its lack of action on short-term lets.

The party’s parliamentary co-leader Alison Johnstone called for action at FMQs, after a Scottish Government consultation overwhelmingly endorsed the Scottish Green position to regulate short term letting through both planning and licensing reform.

This week SNP MSPs in Edinburgh signed a letter calling for urgent reform, even though they had voted with the Tories during the Planning Bill to block similar proposals from Green MSP Andy Wightman.