Tue 24 Jan, 2017

Despite all the uncertainty of global politics and economics, a citizen’s income could help us Glaswegians regain some control in 2017.

In many ways 2016 was a bad year for progressives. Welfare cuts, unfair work conditions and food banks remained; attitudes hardened towards refugees and immigrants; and right wing populists won the vote over Brexit and the White House. But, behind all of this, 2016 was also a year in which those wanting a more economically just, open and equal world also made their mark.

In Glasgow, local people met in community halls to plan local currencies, held protests to force the closure over Dungavel, and community food projects helped to bring neighbours whilst also tackling food insecurity. There was also renewed interest in the idea of a universal basic income.

This has been a Scottish Green Party policy for years and it is encouraging to see other Scottish parties now considering it. We now have a Citizen’s Basic Income Network in Scotland and well publicised trials in Finland, the Netherlands and Canada have helped to push this idea into the spotlight.

Unusually for an economic idea, it gains support from across the political divide, with both those in the traditionally ‘right’ and ‘left’ lending their support to the idea of piloting it. So what is it all about?

Critics point out that it is free money and will do nothing to encourage the ‘work-shy’ to seek employment. But this is to misunderstand two key trends of the labour market. First of all, the current punishment system of welfare conditionality is clearly not working. You just need to watch I, Daniel Blake to see how a guilty until proven innocent approach is not only morally wrong but clearly failing individuals keen to work.

Secondly, we must also remember that for many people in our society, full-time work is never going to be the better option. Some have health conditions which will be severely worsened by work, whilst many others perform invaluable caring roles, which saves the public purse millions every year.

Many people who have never experienced poverty might be forgiven for thinking the current system is fine: surely any job is better than being on benefits. But our current system often forces people to take low-paid, insecure work with little or no promotion opportunities. People feel trapped in poverty, with little or no job satisfaction.

A citizen’s basic income would allow individuals the stability to look for jobs better suited to their circumstances, which means they are more likely to be satisfied at work and therefore more productive, benefitting employers and employees alike.

Also, it is an income, not social security, so additional support should continue to be given to those facing additional societal barriers, such as individuals with disabilities.

The advent of the welfare state was a great achievement, bringing a degree of economic stability to the lives of many. But the economic world in which we live in is in many ways different from 1945 and we need an updated system

It is unclear how exactly the pilots in Glasgow and Fife will be funded, or how it will link in with our complex tax and benefit system. So it is important to regard this pilot as a learning experience, one which will unlikely go perfectly smoothly first time. Also, we all must be clear that a basic income will not hold all of the answers.

But, for many people on low incomes in Glasgow and elsewhere in Scotland, little is going smoothly at the moment. Insecure work contracts, benefit delays, constantly changing welfare system with yet more cuts, means there is no stability, never mind economic justice, in the current model.

 

Get involved

More like this

EU Elections 2019 - Thank You

Fri 31 May, 2019

The European Elections are now over, and although the Green Wave didn't quite hit Scotland's shores there was still a positive result and gains were made in Glasgow.  Patrick Harvie has a message for everyone who campaigned in Glasgow, why they should be proud of Glasgow's results, and what we can do going forwards.

Earth Day Alert

Mon 22 Apr, 2019

Today is Earth Day. To celebrate we urge all members of the Glasgow branch to fill in Glasgow City Council's Climate Change survey to make sure that the Climate Emergency Working Group gets a clear message that Glasgow residents demand more action.

The survey can be found here: www.smartsurvey.co.uk/s/ClimateChange2019/ . To help you complete the survey we've provided some sample answers based on our manifesto commitments and other proposals as suggested by our branch's Climate Emergency Working Group.

A Greener Future for Byres Road

Fri 19 Apr, 2019

Last year Greens warned [https://greens.scot/glasgow/news/9-million-byres-road-plans-risk-a-misse... that the £9 million investment in Byres Road risked being a missed opportunity, with timid plans that did nothing to tackle congestion or air pollution, and that failed to provide the sort of safe infrastructure needed to make walking and cycling attractive and encourage people to stop using cars for short journeys.