Wed 29 Nov, 2017

Ross Greer MSP

West of Scotland
External Affairs, Education & Skills, Culture & Media


The Boundary Commission for Scotland recently announced their revised proposals for Westminster Constituency boundaries. The task they have been set is to reduce the number of MPs and constituencies in Scotland from 59 to 53, and to ensure that the number of voters in each constituency is within a narrow range. This arises from the coalition agreement in 2010 between the Tories and Lib Dems to reduce the total number of MPs from 650 to 600. Despite constant talk of these plans being abandoned by Theresa May’s government, the commission’s work is still going ahead and plans are still on the table.

Greens have consistently opposed a reduction in the number of MPs. While “fewer politicians please” may be the mantra of much of the right wing media, this attitude ignores the fact that a reduction in the number of MPs means a loss of representation for people. It means that people are less likely to have an MP local to them. It means larger constituencies and MPs are increasingly stretched in order to support their constituents and their communities, and this hits the people most in need of support from an MP- such as those experiencing problems with the immigration or welfare systems- the hardest. It means fewer back-bench MPs, fewer people whose job it is to hold the government to account. Under first past the post, larger constituencies play into the hands of larger parties, which means that our parliament becomes even less proportional than it is at the moment. Finally, particularly when combined with strict rules on size of constituency, it means that it’s harder to have constituencies that reflect a real community.

When I mention a real community, one that springs to mind is Bearsden, which I know well. So I was particularly disappointed to hear that the Boundary Commission have revised their proposal from one which splits Bearsden in half, to one which takes around a quarter of Bearsden (North of the station and west of Drymen Road) and combines it with West Dunbartonshire. Splitting a community in this way makes little sense when so many issues affect a community as a whole. We need MPs who represent recognisable communities that are understood by people who live in them. We need MPs who have strong local links and can advocate on behalf of their constituents. Leaving an even smaller part of Bearsden tagged on to West Dunbartonshire makes even less sense.

The Boundary Commission have been set an impossible task and have done their best to listen to the feedback they have been given. The result shows that the right thing to do is to abandon the whole charade. While some may wish to suggest alternatives, such as splitting other communities in East Dunbartonshire, there is no solution that works for everyone, and there are communities up and down the country who are facing similarly unsolvable problems. I encourage as many constituents as possible to respond to the current consultation and suggest that they raise objections to communities being split. You have until 11th December. I would also encourage you to write to your MP and ask them to support scrapping the idea of reducing the number of MPs. It’s doubtful that the Prime Minister can now get a majority of MPs to support the plans, let’s make sure of it.

Get involved

More like this

Scottish Ministers under pressure after FM's non-answer to Ross Greer over Prestwick role in Syrian airstrikes

Thu 19 Apr, 2018

Scottish Ministers are under pressure to explain whether Scottish Government-owned Prestwick airport was used for the recent Syrian airstrikes, following Nicola Sturgeon's evasive non-answer to Green MSP Ross Greer at today's First Minister's Questions.

Scottish Greens previously raised concerns about US military use of the site, with party co-convener Patrick Harvie MSP challenging the First Minister in February following revelations in the Guardian newspaper.

Further fall in ASN teachers amid increase in pupils - situation "completely unacceptable", says Greer

Wed 18 Apr, 2018

Analysis by the Scottish Greens has revealed that the number of specialist Additional Support Needs (ASN) teachers has fallen for the fifth year in a row, while the number of children with identified additional needs has increased by over 65,000 in the same period.

This has resulted in the ratio of young people with additional support needs to specialist ASN teachers trebling in just seven years, reaching the highest level since new laws came in to ensure support in 2010, a situation the Greens say is “completely unacceptable”.

Greer raises community and expansion concerns in response to Glasgow Airport flightpaths consultation

Fri 13 Apr, 2018

Green MSP for the West of Scotland, Ross Greer, has raised concerns about disruption to communities and the prospect of climate-damaging expansion in his response to Glasgow Airport’s flightpaths consultation.